|
|
Chapter 3: Follow-up studies in chronological order
Zingg, König, Cornu, Wildholz & Blaser, 1980
Medical, Urological and Psychiatric Clinic,
University Clinic Bern, Bern, Switzerland
The publication reports
about females treated in Bern. The main emphasis of the
representation lies on technical questions of the
urological and plastic surgery interventions and the
complications that occurred. This is the urological
pendant of the psychiatric dissertation of Simona-Politta
(1983). The same sample is described that, at the same
time, is an expanded partial sample of operated patients
described in the publication of König et al. (1978). For
a general characterization of the patients of Bern, the
works of König et al. (1978), Simona-Politta (1983) and
Dudle (1979) are referred to.
| Sample |
Females
(MFT) |
| Operated and followed-up |
19 |
| Type of Treatment* |
| Penectomy/orchidectomy |
19 |
| Breast enlargement |
19 |
| Vaginoplasty |
19 |
| *Fifteen patients were
diagnosed, prepared and operated by the Bern
team. Three were operated somewhere else by the
primary author; one patient was pre-operated
somewhere else and came to Bern only for a
corrective surgery. A total of 20 surgical
procedures were done for 19 patients. |
| Surgical Complications |
| Local abscess |
4 |
| Functional vaginal
stenosis* |
2 |
| General vaginal stenosis |
8 |
| *The author classified
those stenoses that happened in connection with
sexual excitement and were caused by part of the
erectile tissue that was left at the vagina
entrance as functional ones. |
Study
Methods
Regular follow-up controls were made by
endocrinologists, in greater intervals also by
psychiatrists and surgeons. Specific research instruments
or methods are not mentioned.
Evaluation Fields and
Criteria
Evaluation fields and criteria are not
mentioned. Mainly surgical results and complications are
referred to. Aspects of social evaluations are referred
to briefly.
Results
Of the 12 females whose primary surgeries were
further than one year back, seven were satisfied with
the achieved results. Four had sexual difficulties (pain
during sexual intercourse, non-orgasmic). Two of them
desired corrective surgery. In one female
additionally two corrective procedures were necessary.
"The achieved result is now so good that, according
to the patient -- who works as a prostitute -- even the
most demanding clients achieve their desires" (p.
74).
"From a cosmetic point of view, the result of
the vaginoplasty can be evaluated as satisfactory to very
good" (p. 74). With one exception, all females are socially
integrated. One female is in a psychiatric clinic
because of a psychopathy and a slight debility; the sex
reassignment has conduced a great improvement and a
relaxation in a previously suicidal and pyromaniac
patient. Four females have continuous relationships with
a male or are married. None of the females regrets the
surgery.
Follow-up Studies Mentioned
Benjamin, 1966; Hamburger et al., 1953;
Hastings, 1974; Hore et al., 1975; König et al., 1978;
Laub & Fisk,1974; Pauly, 1965, 1968; Steiner, 1976;
Stürup, 1976; Turner et al., 1978
Authors' Conclusion
"(a) With transsexuals, an
interdisciplinary working group must examine the patient
in depth and repeatedly before any type of sex
reassigning therapy is started. (b) Every irreversible
surgery has to be preceded by an at least one-year-long,
possibly longer, trial period of the hormone treatment
and the living in the desired role (cross-dressing). (c)
The patient must be informed by different physicians of
the working group about the type of hormonal and surgical
treatments as well as possibilities and limitations. (d)
The patient has to always be reminded that the patient
needs life-long hormonal substitution treatment after
surgery, not only because of his sexual needs, but also
because of the need of anabolic hormones" (p. 75).
|