|
|
Chapter 3: Follow-up studies in chronological order
Blanchard, Legault & Lindsay, 1987
Clarke Institute of Psychiatry and University of
Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
This publication contains
a partial aspect of a follow-up study that was already
described previously. While there the psycho-social
variables were presented (Blanchard et al., 1985), this
publication is about the cosmetic and functional
evaluation of the surgical results.
| Sample |
Females
(MFT) |
| Operated and followed-up |
22 |
| Type of Treatment |
| Vaginoplasty |
22 |
| Age at
Time of Surgery |
| Mean |
32.3 years |
| Range |
22.8-59.5 years |
| Follow-up Time Since Surgery |
| Mean |
4.4 years |
| Range |
0.5-11.8 years |
| Age at Time of Follow-up Study |
| Mean |
36.8 years |
| Range |
26.9-64.1 years |
Study
Methods
The secondary author conducted a structured
interview and a physical examination with each female.
Evaluation Fields and
Criteria
Evaluated were the depth, width and the
capacity to function of the vagina as well as the
cosmetic results in the area of the vulva. Additionally,
the number of corrective surgeries, incontinence,
direction of the urine flow, capacity for orgasms,
ejaculation during orgasm, sexual intercourse experience
after surgery, pain or difficulties during sexual
intercourse, difficulties after sexual intercourse and
clitoris erection during intercourse were registered.
Results
Nineteen of the 22 females had at least one
post-surgical sexual intercourse experience. The
frequency of sexual intercourse varied greatly.
Four females reported that they had never had an orgasm
since surgery and seven reported that they had them
seldom, or had difficulties to achieve them. Four
experienced the post-surgical orgasm less intensely as
before. Seven females reported about orgasms, but did not
describe them. Eight females never had pain or
difficulties during sexual intercourse. Five females
reported that pain or difficulties only happened at the
beginning or after a longer sexual inactivity. Four
females only had pain when the penis of the partner was
too big. Two females regularly had pain or difficulties
during sexual intercourse. Three females reported about
pain after sexual intercourse.
The cosmetic results were evaluated for two
females as unsatisfactory, for ten as fair to good and
for nine as very good. Corrective surgical procedures were
necessary for seven females. The average depth of the
vagina was 8.3 cm. (4.0-13.0 cm.). There was no
correlation between the objective measure of the depth
and the subjective evaluation of the females to the
question if the vagina was deep enough for sexual
intercourse. To the contrary, there was a highly
significant connection between regular dilation and the
depth of the vagina.
Follow-up Studies Mentioned
Ball, 1981; Benjamin, 1966; Blanchard et al.,
1985; Hoenig et al., 1971; Lindemalm et al., 1976;
Lothstein, 1980; McEwan et al., 1986; Randell, 1969;
Sörensen, 1981a; Wålinder & Thuwe, 1975; Pomeroy,
1969; Stürup, 1976
Authors' Conclusion
It was the authors' intent to obtain reliable
data about the cosmetic and functional results of
vaginoplasty that they could use for pre-surgical
counseling. The results were called provisional because
they all stem out of the series of one treatment team.
Two important results are especially highlighted: (1) the
post-surgical sexual activity correlates to the quality
of the cosmetic and functional surgical results; (2) even
with a vagina evaluated by the researchers as too short,
the females have had sexual intercourse and experienced
it as satisfactory.
|