Chapter 3: Follow-up studies in chronological order
Kockott & Fahrner, 1988
Psychiatric Clinic of the Technical University and
the Max-Planck-Institute for Psychiatry, Munich, Germany
In this publication
transsexuals of both genders are compared without
regarding the treatment level. This is no follow-up study
in the narrow sense of the word. Specific follow-up study
aspects of the described sample can be found in Fahrner
et al. (1987) that reports about the same sample.
| Sample |
Females
(MFT) |
Males (FMT) |
| Total group |
(38) |
(21) |
| Age at Time of Study |
| Mean |
24.9 years |
32.1 years |
| Range |
8.2 years |
6.4 years |
Study
Methods
See Fahrner et al. (1987)
Evaluation Fields and
Criteria
The groups of MFTs and FMTs were compared,
without regarding the state of the treatment, in view of
the following criteria: contacts to the family,
partnerships, sexual satisfaction and suicide attempts.
Results
At the time of diagnosis the FMTs were
integrated significantly better socially than the group
of MFTs. Twelve of the 19 FMTs , but only a third of the
MFTs, had close contact to the family. Similar
differences were also demonstrated in regard to
partnerships. Two-thirds of the FMTs had mostly
satisfying partnerships (longer than six months); in
comparison, only half of the MFTs had a partner and a
majority (16 of 18) of these were unsatisfied with the
partnership. Sexually satisfied were 80% of the FMTs,
where the same percentage of the MFTs said to be
unsatisfied.
In the follow-up study there was no difference
between MFTs and FMTs regarding the characteristics of
psycho-social integration. In comparison to that, the
FMTs had statistically significant more frequent and
longer partnerships post-surgically than the operated
MFTs and also were more satisfied sexually.
Suicide Attempts/Role
Re-reversal
Eight MFTs and one FMT had attempted suicide;
only one of these suicide attempts happened after
surgery.
Follow-up Studies Mentioned
Blanchard et al., 1985; Hunt & Hampson,
1980; Kröhn et al., 1981; Lundström et al., 1984;
Pauly, 1974; Spengler, 1980; Wålinder, 1967
Authors' Conclusion
The prognosis for FMTs is better than for MFTs
because the former integrate better into the new gender
role. MFTs are more satisfied post-surgically than
before, but their partnership attitude does not
fundamentally change. Even though FMTs can achieve less
by surgical procedures than MFTs they are more stable in
partnerships. The authors believe that the differences
could possibly be found in the genes.
Remarks
To use genetic factors as a recourse to
describe the different partnership behaviors seems not
very plausible.
|