|
|
Chapter 3: Follow-up studies in chronological order
Täschner & Wiesbeck, 1988a
Psychiatric Clinic of the Bürgerhospital, Stuttgart,
Germany
This congress report for
the 8th World Congress for Sexology in Heidelberg,
Germany, contains a great amount of data without
clarifying the purpose of the authors. It seems to be
important to them to have reached the remarkable
conclusion that there is no specific transsexual
personality structure and that psychopathic traits cannot
be corrected immediately by surgery.
| Sample |
Females
(MFT) |
Males (FMT) |
| Total group* |
15 |
7 |
| Operated** |
16 |
| *All patients were seen
because of a first name, resp., legal change
application under the German Transsexual Law
between 1982-84 (see Wiesbeck & Täschner,
1989) **Not
differentiated by gender
|
| Type of Treatment |
| Hormones 22 |
|
|
| Surgery* |
16 |
| *Not specified |
| Age |
| Mean |
31 years |
28 years |
| Range |
21-65 years |
21-37 years |
Follow-Up Study Period
"Most surgeries had been done
shortly before, so that a reliable evaluation of the
success was impossible" (p. 201).
Study
Methods
Psychiatric examination within the procedure
to change first name, resp., legal sex, in accordance to
the Transsexual Law; determination of the intelligence
quotient.
Evaluation Fields and
Criteria
Somatic illnesses, psychopathologic findings,
the start of transsexual symptoms, sexual activity,
partnership, gender of prospective partners, work
relations and suicide attempts were documented.
Results
"Most surgeries had been done shortly
before, so that a reliable evaluation of the success was
impossible. At least most clients had found a certain
emotional tranquility and stability" (p. 201).
Suicide Attempts
Seven patients had attempted suicide one or
more times pre-surgically. Nothing is known about
post-surgical suicide attempts.
Authors' Conclusion
"The surgical correction of primary
gender characteristics cannot be the treatment of choice.
If a surgical solution is desired or being tried, at
least a two-year-long probation period, including
psychotherapy, should be a prerequisite. We see a
surgical intervention as a last resort, not a first
selection" (p. 201).
|